PhD Thesis: “Muslims and palliative care in a Western context: An exploratory qualitative investigation”

Author: George Muishout

Supervisors: Pof. Gerard Wiegers and Prof. Hanneke van Laarhoven

University: Faculty of Humanities, Amsterdam School of Historical Studies (ASH)

Date of Award: May 2, 2023

Abstract

This thesis focuses on the role of religion in palliative settings involving Muslim doctors or religious professionals and Muslim patients and their relatives. It seeks to answer the question how religion shapes Muslim attitudes in medical decision-making in palliative care in the Netherlands.

The thesis demonstrates that in classical Islamic discourse, medical treatment may be withheld or terminated in the case of incurable illness, while modern Islamic discourse tends to put great emphasis on prolonging life through maximum treatment.

The results of the empirical part of the thesis suggest that the professional practice of Turkish imams and Muslim doctors regarding palliative decision making are embedded in the religious and medical institutions they represent and cater to the demands that are part of their jobs within these institutions.

The thesis demonstrates that Muslim doctors take a comfort-oriented approach aimed at preventing suffering from pain, which for some of them conflicts with their personal religious beliefs. Turkish imams predominately advocate for maximum treatment in their advice regarding medical decision-making to their congregants, for the conviction that all Muslims involved will be held accountable by God for questioning His omnipotence.

Together the results create the picture of a healthcare environment in which medical practice and religious beliefs are rather at odds.

Table of contents

• Introduction
• Muslims and medical treatment: An exploration of the ethical-legal status of treatment within the Sunni Islamic tradition
• Muslim jurisprudence on withdrawing treatment from incurable patients: A directed content analysis of the Islamic Fiqh Council of the Muslim World League
• Turkish imams and their role in decision-making in palliative care. A directed content and narrative analysis
• Muslim physicians and palliative care: Attitudes towards the use of palliative sedation
• Muslim doctors and decision making in palliative care: A discourse analysis
• General discussion

Read the full thesis HERE.

Source: University of Amsterdam